Friday, 24 February 2017

23.02.17 - short study notes of dee brown

23.02.17


In order to understand bury my heart at wounded knee, the context of the author first needs to be understood. Therefore taking the format of my study notes for historians i have looked at dee brown and his approach to history.


  • Who are the historians:
identity
biographical details
  • Born 1908
  • Died 2002
  • Occupations: writer, historian, librarian (critical to work as historian, allowed him to research primary sources such as indian treaties in their own words)
philosophy of history
  • For the reader to understand the present circumstances of mistreated people by knowing what happened to them. Know the past to understand present.
approaches to the construction of history
  • Evidence based
bias
  • Focus on native american viewpoint.
context
gender:  male
Ethnicity: american - not native indian
Time: 20th century, BMH written 1970s
Place: america, little rock


"Dee Brown was a born historian. He found things that nobody else ever had, and brought things to life that would've remained buried for centuries—if not forever." (Dick Cavett) 1


  • What are the aims and purposes of history:


The aims and purposes of specific historical debates
  • Dee brown focuses on the 1840s america and the conflicts between the indians and settlers.
  • “History was so important to him. He just wanted it to be told right - to dispel the myth of the west and instead build something real” (linda brown - daughter) 2


Changing interpretations and perspectives of the aims and purposes of history
  • History should be a tool to understand the injustices of today.
  • How has history been constructed and recorded overtime:


Changing methods of historians
  • Brown uses an evidence based approach, using the accounts of native americans and white american to depict the story of what happened.
  • He does not uses it with his own opinion, merely states the evidence he has found.


How historians work
  • Uses library experience to access: records, accounts and archives.
  • Writes for academic audience
  • Writes about social and national concerns


Types of history:
  • Dee brown uses
    • Council records
  • Authobiographies
  • First hand descriptions
  • Researched in national libraries
  • Interviewed native americans


  • Why have approaches to history changed overtime:


The availability of the historical evidence
  • As a librarian he was able to access first hand accounts in archives.


The context of historians
  • During 1968, a tribe of native americans identifying as the indians of all tribes occupied alcatraz island in a demonstration of the rights of native americans. With this growing awareness of indian mistreatment, dee brown wrote bury my heart. 3


Changing interpretations and perspectives about approaches to the construction of history
Changing philosophies of history  *unclear on the 1970s period, need to ask mr wright.


1 Dee Brown, [online video] , 17.06.13, https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Lf4iadqaolA (accessed 23.02.27)
2 Dee Brown, [online video], 17.06.13, https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Lf4iadqaolA (accessed 23.02.27)
3 C Hartmann, 1969: ‘Indians of All Tribes’ group occupies Alcatraz Island, [website], 2011, https://www.nlm.nih.gov/nativevoices/timeline/520.html (accessed 25.02.17)

Wednesday, 8 February 2017

09.02.17 - focus and subsidiary questions draft

09.02.17

brainstorming my question and the required fields i will be researching to answer:

question -
1. assess the impact of dee browns bury my heart at wounded knee in relation to the representation of native indians in american culture over time. (draft one) 

2. assess the importance of dee browns bury my heart at wounded knee as a work of history and its impact on american culture. (final) 

enquiry questions -
key: red indicate key points to include
  1. what was the common attitude towards native americans and the settlement of america prior to 1970? (mention Indians of all Tribes) 
  2. what were dee browns intentions for bury my heart at wounded knee?
  3. how are literary techniques and method of representing used to communicate his intentions?(critical analysis of the work)
  4. what were the responses of the audience at the time and how did the attitude change post publication? (mention Indians of all Tribes)
  5. what are other influences in changing the representation of native americans? (mention "the earth is weeping" as a challenge in change)
  6. does the book hold any relevance today? (mention current conflict at standing rock over Dakota pipeline) 
reading list -

  • attitudes towards native americans pre and post bury my heart. i found a website in relation to the american attitudes, while it does not include dee browns impact, it includes other impacts such as hollywood.1
  • times magazine archives 
  • wikipedia 
  • indian corn 1971 september new york review. 
  • dee brown death articles. 

conversation with mr wright - ( points to research) 

- changed my question. 
- research reviews of time 1970 in time archives.
- review aims of dee brown in introduction and other sources 
        - why at the time of 1971 was it necessary ( context)
- relate to history extension syllabus 
         - ask about whether it is valid for historians to use book for deliberate intentions of change ( this impacts book as it selects for his purpose)

1. C. Brookeman, Native american peoples of the united states, 1990, (website), http://www.americansc.org.uk/Online/brookman.htm, (accessed 9th February 2017).